mirrors/pikasTech-HWLAB
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Merge pull request #127 from pikasTech/fix/m5-live-gate-agg

Browse Source 
Refresh M5 live gate aggregator
This commit is contained in:
Lyon
2026-05-22 20:02:14 +08:00
committed by GitHub
parent 9c4ac48b31 80e8a2f208
commit 0614202f81
5 changed files with 471 additions and 32 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
docs/dev-evidence-blocker-aggregator.md
+23 -4
View File
@@ -48,22 +48,41 @@ without promoting the full gate:
| Layer | Meaning |
| --- | --- |
| `Frontend DEV revision` | Latest accepted Cloud Workbench frontend revision on the active `http://74.48.78.17:16666/` browser endpoint. Frontend revision evidence is browser-only and cannot green DB, M3, M4, or M5. |
| `EDGE/ROUTE live` | `16666` browser and `16667` health route evidence from read-only probes. |
| `DB live/degraded` | Cloud API DB readiness from redacted health evidence; route success does not imply DB live. |
| `M3 hardware trusted loop` | Real DEV `res_boxsimu_1:DO1 -> hwlab-patch-panel -> res_boxsimu_2:DI1` plus operation, trace, audit, and evidence identifiers. |
| `M4 agent loop` | Agent loop live preflight and scheduling/evidence closure, gated by DB and runtime readiness. |
| `artifact/desired-state source` | Artifact source coverage for the current target ref plus desired-state dry-run/apply status. |
The report also emits `activeEndpoints` and `deprecatedEndpoints`. Active
acceptance endpoints are:
- frontend/browser: `http://74.48.78.17:16666/`
- API/live: `http://74.48.78.17:16667/health/live`
Legacy public `http://74.48.78.17:6666` and
`http://74.48.78.17:6667` are historical/deprecated only and are not active
green evidence.
`latestFrontendDevFact` records the current #99/#108 frontend fact: revision
`1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131` is accepted on DEV, with
`promotesM3M4M5=false`.
## Current Contract Map
| Milestone | Current visible level | Contract entry |
| --- | --- | --- |
| M0 | `SOURCE` | `docs/m0-contract-audit.md`, protocol schemas, evidence chain examples, M0 validator. |
| M1 | `LOCAL` | `docs/m1-local-smoke.md`, `fixtures/mvp/runtime.json`, `scripts/m1-contract-smoke.mjs`. |
| M2 | `DEV-LIVE` for route only | DEV deploy smoke fixture plus active read-only `16666`/`16667` endpoint smoke. |
| M3 | `LOCAL` | Hardware trusted loop topology fixture and local patch-panel smoke. |
| M4 | `LOCAL` | Agent automation loop fixture, local runtime skeleton, skills commit, evidence, and cleanup smoke. |
| M5 | `DRY-RUN` | MVP e2e dry-run plan and orchestration validator. |
| M2 | `DEV-LIVE` for frontend/route only | DEV deploy smoke fixture plus active read-only `16666`/`16667` endpoint smoke and accepted frontend revision. |
| M3 | `BLOCKED` | Hardware trusted loop topology fixture and local patch-panel smoke exist, but DEV-LIVE operation/trace/audit/evidence IDs are missing. |
| M4 | `BLOCKED` | Agent automation loop fixture and local smoke exist, but live preflight is blocked at DB live readiness. |
| M5 | `BLOCKED` | MVP e2e dry-run plan is green, but bounded DEV-LIVE acceptance is blocked by DB/M3/M4 and source/artifact coverage. |
`milestoneLevelClassification` is the compact M0-M5 answer for command
handoff. `milestoneBlockerClassification` gives the M3/M4/M5 blocker class,
dependency, and required next proof.
## Blocker Posture
internal/dev-report-lifecycle.mjs
+6 -2
View File
@@ -57,11 +57,15 @@ export function findDeprecatedPublicEndpoints(text) {
export function isDeprecatedEndpointAllowedInActiveReport(report, endpoint) {
const legacyEndpoint = report?.runtimeSmoke?.legacyPublicEndpoint;
const deprecatedEndpoint = report?.deprecatedEndpoints?.find?.((item) => item?.endpoint === endpoint);
return Boolean(
legacyEndpoint &&
(legacyEndpoint &&
legacyEndpoint.endpoint === endpoint &&
legacyEndpoint.status === "deprecated" &&
legacyEndpoint.activeGreenEligible === false
legacyEndpoint.activeGreenEligible === false) ||
(deprecatedEndpoint &&
String(deprecatedEndpoint.status ?? "").includes("deprecated") &&
deprecatedEndpoint.activeGreenEligible === false)
);
}
reports/dev-gate/dev-m5-gate-aggregator-v2.json
+210 -16
View File
@@ -20,10 +20,27 @@
"pikasTech/HWLAB#46",
"pikasTech/HWLAB#64"
],
"generatedAt": "2026-05-22T07:23:47.479Z",
"generatedFromCommit": "8e89409dda5d",
"generatedAt": "2026-05-22T11:50:42.733Z",
"generatedFromCommit": "f933a81c83a5",
"environment": "dev",
"endpoint": "http://74.48.78.17:16667",
"frontendEndpoint": "http://74.48.78.17:16666",
"activeEndpoints": {
"frontend": "http://74.48.78.17:16666/",
"apiLive": "http://74.48.78.17:16667/health/live"
},
"deprecatedEndpoints": [
{
"endpoint": "http://74.48.78.17:6666",
"status": "historical/deprecated",
"activeGreenEligible": false
},
{
"endpoint": "http://74.48.78.17:6667",
"status": "historical/deprecated",
"activeGreenEligible": false
}
],
"devOnly": true,
"prodDisabled": true,
"reportLifecycle": {
@@ -99,7 +116,7 @@
"taskId": "dev-m4-agent-loop",
"lifecycleState": "active",
"status": "blocked",
"commitId": "a1c3cb5"
"commitId": "8e89409"
},
"devM5Gate": {
"path": "reports/dev-gate/dev-mvp-gate-report.json",
@@ -121,7 +138,35 @@
"overall": {
"status": "blocked",
"green": false,
"reason": "EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exists on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by artifact source drift, DB live degradation, missing M3 trusted loop operation evidence, and blocked M4 agent-loop preflight."
"reason": "Frontend revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131 and EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exist on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by artifact source drift, DB live degradation, missing M3 trusted loop operation evidence, and blocked M4 agent-loop preflight."
},
"latestFrontendDevFact": {
"revision": "1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131",
"sources": [
"docs/dev-deploy-apply.md",
"docs/cloud-web-workbench.md",
"web/hwlab-cloud-web/index.html",
"web/hwlab-cloud-web/styles.css"
],
"evidence": [
"Cloud Web /health/live accepted revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131",
"Cloud Workbench public browser endpoint is the active frontend route only",
"Frontend load/revision evidence cannot satisfy DB, M3 hardware-loop, M4 agent-loop, or M5 MVP e2e acceptance"
],
"commands": [
"node web/hwlab-cloud-web/scripts/check.mjs",
"node scripts/dev-cloud-workbench-smoke.mjs --static"
],
"summary": "#99/#108 Cloud Workbench revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131 is the latest accepted DEV frontend fact, but it is frontend-only evidence.",
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#99",
"supports": [
"pikasTech/HWLAB#99",
"pikasTech/HWLAB#108",
"pikasTech/HWLAB#78"
],
"endpoint": "http://74.48.78.17:16666/",
"evidenceLevel": "DEV-LIVE",
"promotesM3M4M5": false
},
"dod": {
"status": "blocked",
@@ -184,11 +229,23 @@
]
},
"currentDevLayering": {
"frontendRevision": {
"label": "Frontend DEV revision",
"status": "pass",
"evidenceLevel": "DEV-LIVE",
"summary": "http://74.48.78.17:16666/ serves the accepted Cloud Workbench frontend revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131; this is browser/frontend evidence only.",
"evidence": [
"Cloud Web /health/live accepted revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131",
"Cloud Workbench public browser endpoint is the active frontend route only",
"Frontend load/revision evidence cannot satisfy DB, M3 hardware-loop, M4 agent-loop, or M5 MVP e2e acceptance"
],
"nextRequired": "Keep frontend revision proof separate from DB live readiness, M3 hardware-loop evidence, M4 agent-loop evidence, and M5 acceptance."
},
"edgeRoute": {
"label": "EDGE/ROUTE live",
"status": "pass",
"evidenceLevel": "DEV-LIVE",
"summary": "16666 browser, 16667 /health, and 16667 /health/live returned accepted HWLAB DEV responses in the active M2 read-only smoke.",
"summary": "http://74.48.78.17:16666/, http://74.48.78.17:16667/health, and http://74.48.78.17:16667/health/live returned accepted HWLAB DEV responses in the active M2 read-only smoke.",
"evidence": [
"http://74.48.78.17:16667/health -> HTTP 200 identity=hwlab-edge-proxy status=ok",
"http://74.48.78.17:16667/health/live -> HTTP 200 identity=hwlab-cloud-api status=degraded",
@@ -245,6 +302,103 @@
"nextRequired": "Refresh artifact/source coverage for current origin/main and keep desired-state apply separate from read-only route proof."
}
},
"milestoneLevelClassification": [
{
"milestone": "M0",
"currentLevel": "SOURCE",
"status": "pass",
"strongestEvidenceLevel": "SOURCE",
"liveEvidence": "missing_or_blocked",
"summary": "Source contract is green at source level only."
},
{
"milestone": "M1",
"currentLevel": "LOCAL",
"status": "pass",
"strongestEvidenceLevel": "LOCAL",
"liveEvidence": "missing_or_blocked",
"summary": "Local smoke is green; it is not DEV-LIVE."
},
{
"milestone": "M2",
"currentLevel": "DEV-LIVE",
"status": "blocked",
"strongestEvidenceLevel": "DEV-LIVE",
"liveEvidence": "pass",
"summary": "Current public frontend/API route evidence is DEV-LIVE for route/front-end reachability only."
},
{
"milestone": "M3",
"currentLevel": "BLOCKED",
"status": "blocked",
"strongestEvidenceLevel": "LOCAL",
"liveEvidence": "missing_or_blocked",
"summary": "DEV-LIVE hardware trusted loop is blocked; local/source shape is not acceptance."
},
{
"milestone": "M4",
"currentLevel": "BLOCKED",
"status": "blocked",
"strongestEvidenceLevel": "DRY-RUN",
"liveEvidence": "missing_or_blocked",
"summary": "DEV-LIVE agent loop is blocked at DB live readiness; local smoke is not acceptance."
},
{
"milestone": "M5",
"currentLevel": "BLOCKED",
"status": "blocked",
"strongestEvidenceLevel": "DRY-RUN",
"liveEvidence": "missing_or_blocked",
"summary": "Dry-run is green, but bounded DEV-LIVE MVP e2e is blocked."
}
],
"milestoneBlockerClassification": [
{
"milestone": "M3",
"status": "blocked",
"currentLevel": "BLOCKED",
"blockerClass": "hardware-loop-runtime",
"dependency": "Real DEV trusted loop through res_boxsimu_1:DO1 -> hwlab-patch-panel -> res_boxsimu_2:DI1.",
"evidence": [
"operationId=not_observed",
"traceId=not_observed",
"auditId=not_observed",
"evidenceId=not_observed"
],
"nextRequired": "Run the bounded DEV M3 live smoke only after patch-panel topology can prove operation, trace, audit, and evidence IDs.",
"nonPromotionReason": "Public frontend, route, and artifact evidence do not prove the required hardware loop."
},
{
"milestone": "M4",
"status": "blocked",
"currentLevel": "BLOCKED",
"blockerClass": "db-live-readiness",
"dependency": "Cloud API /health/live must report DB ready=true, connected=true, and liveDbEvidence=true before live agent scheduling/evidence closure.",
"evidence": [
"db.status=degraded",
"db.ready=false",
"db.connected=false",
"db.liveDbEvidence=false"
],
"nextRequired": "Repair DB live readiness and rerun the M4 live preflight without scheduling a DEV agent task before preconditions pass.",
"nonPromotionReason": "Frontend revision and read-only route reachability do not prove DB-backed agent runtime readiness."
},
{
"milestone": "M5",
"status": "blocked",
"currentLevel": "BLOCKED",
"blockerClass": "composite-db-m3-m4-live",
"dependency": "M5 needs DB live readiness, M3 trusted-loop DEV evidence, M4 live preflight/evidence closure, and current source/artifact coverage.",
"evidence": [
"M5 dry-run is green",
"db.ready=false",
"m3.live=false",
"m4.live=false"
],
"nextRequired": "After DB/M3/M4 blockers are cleared, run only the bounded DEV MVP live gate command with explicit DEV/non-PROD confirmations.",
"nonPromotionReason": "No frontend, route-only, local, or dry-run evidence is allowed to stand in for bounded DEV-LIVE MVP e2e acceptance."
}
],
"milestones": [
{
"id": "M0",
@@ -269,7 +423,7 @@
"status": "blocked",
"highestVisibleLevel": "DEV-LIVE",
"liveEvidence": "pass",
"evidenceCount": 6,
"evidenceCount": 7,
"blockerCount": 5,
"summary": "deploy/runtime readiness is blocked before live DEV; highest visible level is DEV-LIVE; status is blocked."
},
@@ -285,11 +439,11 @@
{
"id": "M4",
"status": "blocked",
"highestVisibleLevel": "LOCAL",
"highestVisibleLevel": "DRY-RUN",
"liveEvidence": "missing_or_blocked",
"evidenceCount": 3,
"blockerCount": 2,
"summary": "agent loop has local smoke but live preflight is blocked; highest visible level is LOCAL; status is blocked."
"summary": "agent loop has local smoke but live preflight is blocked; highest visible level is DRY-RUN; status is blocked."
},
{
"id": "M5",
@@ -340,6 +494,31 @@
],
"summary": "Local skeleton smoke covers cloud API, simulators, patch-panel routing, CLI dry-run boundary, and no DEV/PROD mutation."
},
{
"milestone": "M2",
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#99",
"taskId": "cloud-web-workbench-frontend",
"lifecycleState": "active",
"level": "DEV-LIVE",
"status": "pass",
"category": "frontend-dev-revision",
"sources": [
"docs/dev-deploy-apply.md",
"docs/cloud-web-workbench.md",
"web/hwlab-cloud-web/index.html",
"web/hwlab-cloud-web/styles.css"
],
"commands": [
"node web/hwlab-cloud-web/scripts/check.mjs",
"node scripts/dev-cloud-workbench-smoke.mjs --static"
],
"evidence": [
"Cloud Web /health/live accepted revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131",
"Cloud Workbench public browser endpoint is the active frontend route only",
"Frontend load/revision evidence cannot satisfy DB, M3 hardware-loop, M4 agent-loop, or M5 MVP e2e acceptance"
],
"summary": "#99/#108 Cloud Workbench revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131 is the latest accepted DEV frontend fact, but it is frontend-only evidence."
},
{
"milestone": "M2",
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#34",
@@ -552,7 +731,7 @@
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#37",
"taskId": "dev-m4-agent-loop",
"reportPath": "reports/dev-gate/dev-m4-agent-loop.json",
"commitId": "a1c3cb5",
"commitId": "8e89409",
"lifecycleState": "active",
"level": "LOCAL",
"status": "pass",
@@ -571,25 +750,31 @@
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#37",
"taskId": "dev-m4-agent-loop",
"reportPath": "reports/dev-gate/dev-m4-agent-loop.json",
"commitId": "a1c3cb5",
"commitId": "8e89409",
"lifecycleState": "active",
"level": "DRY-RUN",
"status": "not_run",
"status": "pass",
"category": "agent-loop-dry-run",
"commands": [
"node scripts/dev-m4-agent-loop-smoke.mjs --dry-run"
],
"evidence": [
"No dry-run output is attached to the live preflight report."
"hwlab-agent-mgr:session=agt_m4_agent_loop_01:created=queued:final=cleanup",
"hwlab-agent-worker:session=wkr_agt_m4_agent_loop_01:status=cleanup",
"workspace:vol_agt_m4_agent_loop_01:cleaned=true:existsAfterCleanup=false",
"hwlab-agent-skills:commit=6509a35:version=v1",
"trace:trc_agt_m4_agent_loop_01:events=5",
"evidence:evi_agt_m4_agent_loop_01:kind=report",
"cleanup:cln_agt_m4_agent_loop_01:removed=true"
],
"summary": "The live preflight report does not attempt a dry-run agent run."
"summary": "Local dry-run covered agent manager, worker, workspace isolation, skills commit, trace, evidence, and cleanup without live DEV mutation."
},
{
"milestone": "M4",
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#37",
"taskId": "dev-m4-agent-loop",
"reportPath": "reports/dev-gate/dev-m4-agent-loop.json",
"commitId": "a1c3cb5",
"commitId": "8e89409",
"lifecycleState": "active",
"level": "BLOCKED",
"status": "blocked",
@@ -740,10 +925,10 @@
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#37",
"taskId": "dev-m4-agent-loop",
"lifecycleState": "active",
"status": "not_run",
"status": "pass",
"category": "agent-loop-dry-run",
"reportPath": "reports/dev-gate/dev-m4-agent-loop.json",
"summary": "The live preflight report does not attempt a dry-run agent run."
"summary": "Local dry-run covered agent manager, worker, workspace isolation, skills commit, trace, evidence, and cleanup without live DEV mutation."
},
{
"milestone": "M5",
@@ -757,6 +942,15 @@
}
],
"DEV-LIVE": [
{
"milestone": "M2",
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#99",
"taskId": "cloud-web-workbench-frontend",
"lifecycleState": "active",
"status": "pass",
"category": "frontend-dev-revision",
"summary": "#99/#108 Cloud Workbench revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131 is the latest accepted DEV frontend fact, but it is frontend-only evidence."
},
{
"milestone": "M2",
"issue": "pikasTech/HWLAB#23",
reports/dev-gate/dev-m5-gate-aggregator-v2.md
+31 -4
View File
@@ -1,23 +1,42 @@
# HWLAB M5 DEV Gate Aggregator v2
Status: blocked
Generated from: `8e89409dda5d`
Generated from: `f933a81c83a5`
Scope: DEV only, report-only
Active frontend: `http://74.48.78.17:16666/`
Active API/live: `http://74.48.78.17:16667/health/live`
Deprecated public endpoints: `http://74.48.78.17:6666`, `http://74.48.78.17:6667`
## Summary
EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exists on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by artifact source drift, DB live degradation, missing M3 trusted loop operation evidence, and blocked M4 agent-loop preflight.
Frontend revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131 and EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exist on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by artifact source drift, DB live degradation, missing M3 trusted loop operation evidence, and blocked M4 agent-loop preflight.
## Frontend DEV Fact
The latest accepted #99/#108 frontend DEV fact is revision `1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131` at `http://74.48.78.17:16666/`. This is DEV-LIVE browser/frontend evidence only and does not promote M3, M4, or M5.
## Current DEV Layering
| Layer | Status | Evidence level | Current conclusion | Required next proof |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| EDGE/ROUTE live | pass | DEV-LIVE | 16666 browser, 16667 /health, and 16667 /health/live returned accepted HWLAB DEV responses in the active M2 read-only smoke. | Keep this separated from DB readiness, M3/M4 loop evidence, and M5 acceptance. |
| Frontend DEV revision | pass | DEV-LIVE | http://74.48.78.17:16666/ serves the accepted Cloud Workbench frontend revision 1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131; this is browser/frontend evidence only. | Keep frontend revision proof separate from DB live readiness, M3 hardware-loop evidence, M4 agent-loop evidence, and M5 acceptance. |
| EDGE/ROUTE live | pass | DEV-LIVE | http://74.48.78.17:16666/, http://74.48.78.17:16667/health, and http://74.48.78.17:16667/health/live returned accepted HWLAB DEV responses in the active M2 read-only smoke. | Keep this separated from DB readiness, M3/M4 loop evidence, and M5 acceptance. |
| DB live/degraded | blocked | BLOCKED | cloud-api DB status=degraded; configReady=true; ready=false; connected=false; liveDbEvidence=false. | Provide live DB connection evidence through redacted health output; route reachability alone is insufficient. |
| M3 hardware trusted loop | blocked | BLOCKED | No live DEV operation has run yet. Blocker: patch-panel active DO1 -> DI1 connection missing. | Only a real DEV res_boxsimu_1:DO1 -> hwlab-patch-panel -> res_boxsimu_2:DI1 observation with operation/trace/audit/evidence can clear M3. |
| M4 agent loop | blocked | BLOCKED | Blocked at DB live readiness before scheduling a DEV agent task. | Do not schedule or claim the agent loop as live until DB live and required runtime/evidence preconditions pass. |
| artifact/desired-state source | blocked | BLOCKED | artifact targetCovered=false; artifactSource=7e29522b65c8; target=8e89409dda5d; desiredApplyMode=dry-run; mutationAttempted=false. | Refresh artifact/source coverage for current origin/main and keep desired-state apply separate from read-only route proof. |
## M0-M5 Level Classification
| Milestone | Current classification | Status | Strongest evidence | Live evidence | Summary |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| M0 | SOURCE | pass | SOURCE | missing_or_blocked | Source contract is green at source level only. |
| M1 | LOCAL | pass | LOCAL | missing_or_blocked | Local smoke is green; it is not DEV-LIVE. |
| M2 | DEV-LIVE | blocked | DEV-LIVE | pass | Current public frontend/API route evidence is DEV-LIVE for route/front-end reachability only. |
| M3 | BLOCKED | blocked | LOCAL | missing_or_blocked | DEV-LIVE hardware trusted loop is blocked; local/source shape is not acceptance. |
| M4 | BLOCKED | blocked | DRY-RUN | missing_or_blocked | DEV-LIVE agent loop is blocked at DB live readiness; local smoke is not acceptance. |
| M5 | BLOCKED | blocked | DRY-RUN | missing_or_blocked | Dry-run is green, but bounded DEV-LIVE MVP e2e is blocked. |
## Milestones
| Milestone | Status | Highest visible level | Live evidence | Summary |
@@ -26,7 +45,7 @@ EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exists on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by
| M1 | pass | LOCAL | missing_or_blocked | local smoke is available; highest visible level is LOCAL; status is pass. |
| M2 | blocked | DEV-LIVE | pass | deploy/runtime readiness is blocked before live DEV; highest visible level is DEV-LIVE; status is blocked. |
| M3 | blocked | LOCAL | missing_or_blocked | hardware loop has source/local shape but no live operation; highest visible level is LOCAL; status is blocked. |
| M4 | blocked | LOCAL | missing_or_blocked | agent loop has local smoke but live preflight is blocked; highest visible level is LOCAL; status is blocked. |
| M4 | blocked | DRY-RUN | missing_or_blocked | agent loop has local smoke but live preflight is blocked; highest visible level is DRY-RUN; status is blocked. |
| M5 | blocked | DRY-RUN | missing_or_blocked | dry-run is green but live MVP gate is blocked; highest visible level is DRY-RUN; status is blocked. |
## #9 DoD Checks
@@ -43,6 +62,14 @@ EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exists on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by
| m4-agent-loop-live | blocked | BLOCKED | M4 agent loop live path is blocked before accepted agent scheduling/evidence closure. |
| m5-mvp-dev-live | blocked | BLOCKED | M5 dry-run passed; bounded DEV-LIVE MVP e2e has not passed. |
## M3/M4/M5 Blocker Classification
| Milestone | Status | Current level | Blocker class | Dependency | Required next proof |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| M3 | blocked | BLOCKED | hardware-loop-runtime | Real DEV trusted loop through res_boxsimu_1:DO1 -> hwlab-patch-panel -> res_boxsimu_2:DI1. | Run the bounded DEV M3 live smoke only after patch-panel topology can prove operation, trace, audit, and evidence IDs. |
| M4 | blocked | BLOCKED | db-live-readiness | Cloud API /health/live must report DB ready=true, connected=true, and liveDbEvidence=true before live agent scheduling/evidence closure. | Repair DB live readiness and rerun the M4 live preflight without scheduling a DEV agent task before preconditions pass. |
| M5 | blocked | BLOCKED | composite-db-m3-m4-live | M5 needs DB live readiness, M3 trusted-loop DEV evidence, M4 live preflight/evidence closure, and current source/artifact coverage. | After DB/M3/M4 blockers are cleared, run only the bounded DEV MVP live gate command with explicit DEV/non-PROD confirmations. |
## Blockers
| Priority | Order | Type | Scope | Summary |
scripts/src/dev-evidence-blocker-aggregator.mjs
+201 -6
View File
@@ -9,8 +9,13 @@ import { DEV_ENDPOINT, DEV_FRONTEND_ENDPOINT, ENVIRONMENT_DEV, SERVICE_IDS } fro
export const repoRoot = path.resolve(path.dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)), "../..");
const deprecatedLegacyPublicPort = 6000 + 667;
const deprecatedLegacyPublicEndpoint = `http://74.48.78.17:${deprecatedLegacyPublicPort}`;
const activeBrowserRoot = `${DEV_FRONTEND_ENDPOINT}/`;
const activeApiLiveEndpoint = `${DEV_ENDPOINT}/health/live`;
const deprecatedLegacyPublicEndpoints = Object.freeze([
"http://74.48.78.17:6666",
"http://74.48.78.17:6667"
]);
const latestFrontendRevision = "1e8805664970839b72be40c34636b08f6d18b131";
const levels = Object.freeze(["SOURCE", "LOCAL", "DRY-RUN", "DEV-LIVE", "BLOCKED"]);
const statusRank = Object.freeze({
pass: 0,
@@ -95,6 +100,26 @@ const sourceContracts = Object.freeze([
}
]);
const frontendDevFact = Object.freeze({
revision: latestFrontendRevision,
sources: [
"docs/dev-deploy-apply.md",
"docs/cloud-web-workbench.md",
"web/hwlab-cloud-web/index.html",
"web/hwlab-cloud-web/styles.css"
],
evidence: [
`Cloud Web /health/live accepted revision ${latestFrontendRevision}`,
"Cloud Workbench public browser endpoint is the active frontend route only",
"Frontend load/revision evidence cannot satisfy DB, M3 hardware-loop, M4 agent-loop, or M5 MVP e2e acceptance"
],
commands: [
"node web/hwlab-cloud-web/scripts/check.mjs",
"node scripts/dev-cloud-workbench-smoke.mjs --static"
],
summary: `#99/#108 Cloud Workbench revision ${latestFrontendRevision} is the latest accepted DEV frontend fact, but it is frontend-only evidence.`
});
function issue(id) {
return `pikasTech/HWLAB#${id}`;
}
@@ -356,6 +381,19 @@ function collectM2Evidence(reports) {
const m2EndpointLive = hasCurrentM2EndpointEvidence(m2Smoke);
return [
{
milestone: "M2",
issue: issue(99),
taskId: "cloud-web-workbench-frontend",
lifecycleState: "active",
level: "DEV-LIVE",
status: "pass",
category: "frontend-dev-revision",
sources: frontendDevFact.sources,
commands: frontendDevFact.commands,
evidence: frontendDevFact.evidence,
summary: frontendDevFact.summary
},
reportEvidence({
milestone: "M2",
level: "SOURCE",
@@ -622,7 +660,7 @@ function publicEndpointEvidence(m2Report) {
function isStaleLegacyIngressBlocker(blocker, sourceReport, reports) {
const text = `${blocker.scope ?? ""} ${blocker.summary ?? ""}`;
const staleLegacyPort = text.includes(deprecatedLegacyPublicEndpoint);
const staleLegacyPort = deprecatedLegacyPublicEndpoints.some((endpoint) => text.includes(endpoint));
const stalePreflightEdgeProbe = sourceReport.path === reportPaths.devPreflight &&
blocker.type === "network_blocker" &&
(blocker.scope === "dev-edge" || blocker.scope === "dev-edge-health") &&
@@ -690,6 +728,34 @@ function summarizeMilestone(milestone, highestVisibleLevel, status) {
return `${labels[milestone]}; highest visible level is ${highestVisibleLevel}; status is ${status}.`;
}
function buildMilestoneLevelClassification(milestones) {
const currentLabels = {
M0: "SOURCE",
M1: "LOCAL",
M2: "DEV-LIVE",
M3: "BLOCKED",
M4: "BLOCKED",
M5: "BLOCKED"
};
const notes = {
M0: "Source contract is green at source level only.",
M1: "Local smoke is green; it is not DEV-LIVE.",
M2: "Current public frontend/API route evidence is DEV-LIVE for route/front-end reachability only.",
M3: "DEV-LIVE hardware trusted loop is blocked; local/source shape is not acceptance.",
M4: "DEV-LIVE agent loop is blocked at DB live readiness; local smoke is not acceptance.",
M5: "Dry-run is green, but bounded DEV-LIVE MVP e2e is blocked."
};
return milestones.map((milestone) => ({
milestone: milestone.id,
currentLevel: currentLabels[milestone.id],
status: milestone.status,
strongestEvidenceLevel: milestone.highestVisibleLevel,
liveEvidence: milestone.liveEvidence,
summary: notes[milestone.id]
}));
}
function groupByLevel(evidence, blockers) {
const grouped = Object.fromEntries(levels.map((level) => [level, []]));
for (const item of evidence) {
@@ -836,13 +902,21 @@ function buildCurrentDevLayering(reports, blockers) {
const artifactSourceStates = artifactSourceStateCounts(reports.devArtifacts);
return {
frontendRevision: {
label: "Frontend DEV revision",
status: "pass",
evidenceLevel: "DEV-LIVE",
summary: `${activeBrowserRoot} serves the accepted Cloud Workbench frontend revision ${latestFrontendRevision}; this is browser/frontend evidence only.`,
evidence: frontendDevFact.evidence,
nextRequired: "Keep frontend revision proof separate from DB live readiness, M3 hardware-loop evidence, M4 agent-loop evidence, and M5 acceptance."
},
edgeRoute: {
label: "EDGE/ROUTE live",
status: m2EndpointLive || edgeLive ? "pass" : "blocked",
evidenceLevel: m2EndpointLive || edgeLive ? "DEV-LIVE" : "BLOCKED",
summary: m2EndpointLive
? "16666 browser, 16667 /health, and 16667 /health/live returned accepted HWLAB DEV responses in the active M2 read-only smoke."
: "No active read-only public endpoint report proves both 16666 and 16667.",
? `${activeBrowserRoot}, ${DEV_ENDPOINT}/health, and ${activeApiLiveEndpoint} returned accepted HWLAB DEV responses in the active M2 read-only smoke.`
: `No active read-only public endpoint report proves both ${activeBrowserRoot} and ${activeApiLiveEndpoint}.`,
evidence: publicEndpointEvidence(reports.devM2Smoke),
nextRequired: "Keep this separated from DB readiness, M3/M4 loop evidence, and M5 acceptance."
},
@@ -890,6 +964,60 @@ function buildCurrentDevLayering(reports, blockers) {
};
}
function buildMilestoneBlockerClassification(reports) {
const cloudDb = cloudApiDbStatus(reports);
const m3Live = statusIsPass(reports.devM3Hardware.liveOperation?.status);
const m4Live = statusIsPass(reports.devM4Agent.livePreflight?.status);
return [
{
milestone: "M3",
status: m3Live ? "pass" : "blocked",
currentLevel: m3Live ? "DEV-LIVE" : "BLOCKED",
blockerClass: m3Live ? "cleared" : "hardware-loop-runtime",
dependency: "Real DEV trusted loop through res_boxsimu_1:DO1 -> hwlab-patch-panel -> res_boxsimu_2:DI1.",
evidence: [
`operationId=${reports.devM3Hardware.liveOperation?.operationId ?? "not_observed"}`,
`traceId=${reports.devM3Hardware.liveOperation?.traceId ?? "not_observed"}`,
`auditId=${reports.devM3Hardware.liveOperation?.auditId ?? "not_observed"}`,
`evidenceId=${reports.devM3Hardware.liveOperation?.evidenceId ?? "not_observed"}`
],
nextRequired: "Run the bounded DEV M3 live smoke only after patch-panel topology can prove operation, trace, audit, and evidence IDs.",
nonPromotionReason: "Public frontend, route, and artifact evidence do not prove the required hardware loop."
},
{
milestone: "M4",
status: m4Live ? "pass" : "blocked",
currentLevel: m4Live ? "DEV-LIVE" : "BLOCKED",
blockerClass: m4Live ? "cleared" : "db-live-readiness",
dependency: "Cloud API /health/live must report DB ready=true, connected=true, and liveDbEvidence=true before live agent scheduling/evidence closure.",
evidence: [
`db.status=${cloudDb.status}`,
`db.ready=${cloudDb.ready}`,
`db.connected=${cloudDb.connected}`,
`db.liveDbEvidence=${cloudDb.liveDbEvidence}`
],
nextRequired: "Repair DB live readiness and rerun the M4 live preflight without scheduling a DEV agent task before preconditions pass.",
nonPromotionReason: "Frontend revision and read-only route reachability do not prove DB-backed agent runtime readiness."
},
{
milestone: "M5",
status: "blocked",
currentLevel: "BLOCKED",
blockerClass: "composite-db-m3-m4-live",
dependency: "M5 needs DB live readiness, M3 trusted-loop DEV evidence, M4 live preflight/evidence closure, and current source/artifact coverage.",
evidence: [
"M5 dry-run is green",
`db.ready=${cloudDb.ready}`,
`m3.live=${m3Live}`,
`m4.live=${m4Live}`
],
nextRequired: "After DB/M3/M4 blockers are cleared, run only the bounded DEV MVP live gate command with explicit DEV/non-PROD confirmations.",
nonPromotionReason: "No frontend, route-only, local, or dry-run evidence is allowed to stand in for bounded DEV-LIVE MVP e2e acceptance."
}
];
}
function artifactSourceStateCounts(artifactReport) {
const counts = { sourcePresent: 0, intentionallyDisabled: 0 };
for (const service of artifactReport.artifactPublish?.services ?? []) {
@@ -964,9 +1092,24 @@ function validateReport(report) {
assert.equal(report.issue, issue(58), "issue");
assert.equal(report.environment, ENVIRONMENT_DEV, "environment");
assert.equal(report.endpoint, DEV_ENDPOINT, "endpoint");
assert.equal(report.frontendEndpoint, DEV_FRONTEND_ENDPOINT, "frontendEndpoint");
assert.equal(report.activeEndpoints.frontend, activeBrowserRoot, "activeEndpoints.frontend");
assert.equal(report.activeEndpoints.apiLive, activeApiLiveEndpoint, "activeEndpoints.apiLive");
assert.equal(report.devOnly, true, "devOnly");
assert.equal(report.prodDisabled, true, "prodDisabled");
assert.deepEqual(Object.keys(report.levels), [...levels], "level keys");
assert.equal(report.latestFrontendDevFact.revision, latestFrontendRevision, "latestFrontendDevFact.revision");
assert.equal(report.latestFrontendDevFact.promotesM3M4M5, false, "frontend fact cannot promote M3/M4/M5");
assert.deepEqual(
report.milestoneLevelClassification.map((item) => item.milestone),
["M0", "M1", "M2", "M3", "M4", "M5"],
"milestoneLevelClassification"
);
assert.deepEqual(
report.milestoneBlockerClassification.map((item) => item.milestone),
["M3", "M4", "M5"],
"milestoneBlockerClassification"
);
assert.ok(report.blockers.length >= 1, "must remain blocked without DEV-LIVE evidence");
assert.equal(report.overall.status, "blocked", "overall status");
assert.ok(report.nextSteps.length >= 1, "next steps required");
@@ -994,8 +1137,10 @@ export async function buildReport() {
];
const blockers = collectBlockers(reports);
const milestones = deriveMilestones(evidence, blockers);
const milestoneLevelClassification = buildMilestoneLevelClassification(milestones);
const dod = buildDoD(reports, milestones, blockers);
const currentDevLayering = buildCurrentDevLayering(reports, blockers);
const milestoneBlockerClassification = buildMilestoneBlockerClassification(reports);
const nextSteps = buildNextSteps(blockers);
const report = {
"$schema": "https://hwlab.pikastech.local/schemas/dev-m5-gate-aggregator-v2.schema.json",
@@ -1008,6 +1153,16 @@ export async function buildReport() {
generatedFromCommit: gitCommit(),
environment: ENVIRONMENT_DEV,
endpoint: DEV_ENDPOINT,
frontendEndpoint: DEV_FRONTEND_ENDPOINT,
activeEndpoints: {
frontend: activeBrowserRoot,
apiLive: activeApiLiveEndpoint
},
deprecatedEndpoints: deprecatedLegacyPublicEndpoints.map((endpoint) => ({
endpoint,
status: "historical/deprecated",
activeGreenEligible: false
})),
devOnly: true,
prodDisabled: true,
reportLifecycle: activeReportLifecycle(
@@ -1041,10 +1196,20 @@ export async function buildReport() {
green: dod.green,
reason: dod.green
? "All #9 DEV DoD checks are green."
: "EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exists on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by artifact source drift, DB live degradation, missing M3 trusted loop operation evidence, and blocked M4 agent-loop preflight."
: `Frontend revision ${latestFrontendRevision} and EDGE/ROUTE DEV-LIVE evidence exist on :16666/:16667, but M5 remains blocked by artifact source drift, DB live degradation, missing M3 trusted loop operation evidence, and blocked M4 agent-loop preflight.`
},
latestFrontendDevFact: {
...frontendDevFact,
issue: issue(99),
supports: [issue(99), issue(108), issue(78)],
endpoint: activeBrowserRoot,
evidenceLevel: "DEV-LIVE",
promotesM3M4M5: false
},
dod,
currentDevLayering,
milestoneLevelClassification,
milestoneBlockerClassification,
milestones,
evidence,
levels: groupByLevel(evidence, blockers),
@@ -1064,6 +1229,11 @@ export function formatCheckSummary(report) {
status: report.overall.status,
green: report.overall.green,
blockers: report.blockers.length,
activeEndpoints: report.activeEndpoints,
frontendRevision: report.latestFrontendDevFact.revision,
m3m4m5: Object.fromEntries(
report.milestoneBlockerClassification.map((item) => [item.milestone, item.status])
),
nextStep: report.nextSteps[0]?.action ?? null,
levels: Object.fromEntries(
Object.entries(report.levels).map(([level, entries]) => [level, entries.length])
@@ -1075,12 +1245,18 @@ export function renderMarkdown(report) {
const layeringLines = Object.entries(report.currentDevLayering)
.map(([, layer]) => `| ${layer.label} | ${layer.status} | ${layer.evidenceLevel} | ${layer.summary} | ${layer.nextRequired} |`)
.join("\n");
const milestoneLevelLines = report.milestoneLevelClassification
.map((item) => `| ${item.milestone} | ${item.currentLevel} | ${item.status} | ${item.strongestEvidenceLevel} | ${item.liveEvidence} | ${item.summary} |`)
.join("\n");
const milestoneLines = report.milestones
.map((milestone) => `| ${milestone.id} | ${milestone.status} | ${milestone.highestVisibleLevel} | ${milestone.liveEvidence} | ${milestone.summary} |`)
.join("\n");
const dodLines = report.dod.checks
.map((check) => `| ${check.id} | ${check.status} | ${check.evidenceLevel} | ${check.summary} |`)
.join("\n");
const blockerClassificationLines = report.milestoneBlockerClassification
.map((item) => `| ${item.milestone} | ${item.status} | ${item.currentLevel} | ${item.blockerClass} | ${item.dependency} | ${item.nextRequired} |`)
.join("\n");
const blockerLines = report.blockers
.map((blocker) => `| ${blocker.priority} | ${blocker.unblockOrder} | ${blocker.type} | ${blocker.scope} | ${blocker.summary} |`)
.join("\n");
@@ -1093,17 +1269,30 @@ export function renderMarkdown(report) {
Status: ${report.overall.status}
Generated from: \`${report.generatedFromCommit}\`
Scope: DEV only, report-only
Active frontend: \`${report.activeEndpoints.frontend}\`
Active API/live: \`${report.activeEndpoints.apiLive}\`
Deprecated public endpoints: ${report.deprecatedEndpoints.map((item) => `\`${item.endpoint}\``).join(", ")}
## Summary
${report.overall.reason}
## Frontend DEV Fact
The latest accepted #99/#108 frontend DEV fact is revision \`${report.latestFrontendDevFact.revision}\` at \`${report.latestFrontendDevFact.endpoint}\`. This is ${report.latestFrontendDevFact.evidenceLevel} browser/frontend evidence only and does not promote M3, M4, or M5.
## Current DEV Layering
| Layer | Status | Evidence level | Current conclusion | Required next proof |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
${layeringLines}
## M0-M5 Level Classification
| Milestone | Current classification | Status | Strongest evidence | Live evidence | Summary |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
${milestoneLevelLines}
## Milestones
| Milestone | Status | Highest visible level | Live evidence | Summary |
@@ -1116,6 +1305,12 @@ ${milestoneLines}
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
${dodLines}
## M3/M4/M5 Blocker Classification
| Milestone | Status | Current level | Blocker class | Dependency | Required next proof |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
${blockerClassificationLines}
## Blockers
| Priority | Order | Type | Scope | Summary |